Cheapest Gas in Ithaca, NY

Updated May 20, 2026 — Prices updated regularly from EIA data

$3.38

Lowest price at Costco in Ithaca

Finding Cheap Gas in Ithaca

Hunting down the lowest gas price in Ithaca, New York is worth the effort. At $$3.38 per gallon at the cheapest outlet versus $$3.63 at the most expensive, you save $$3.75 on every 15-gallon fill-up.

Maximum Savings in Ithaca

Choose Costco over Chevron

$0.25 per gallon

$3.75 per 15-gallon fill • $12.00 per year (est.)

Cheapest Brands in Ithaca

Rank	Brand	Est. Price	Savings vs. Most Expensive
#1	Costco	$3.38	$0.25
#2	Speedway	$3.50	$0.13
#3	Circle K	$3.51	$0.12
#4	Sunoco	$3.54	$0.09
#5	Marathon	$3.55	$0.08
#6	BP	$3.57	$0.06
#7	Mobil	$3.58	$0.05
#8	Exxon	$3.59	$0.04
#9	Shell	$3.61	$0.02
#10	Chevron	$3.63	$0.00

Gas Saving Tips for Ithaca Drivers

Fill up before holiday weekends. Memorial Day, Fourth of July, and Labor Day consistently see 10-25 cent price spikes as demand surges. Topping off Thursday before a holiday weekend beats the rush.
Download the Upside app for cashback on gas purchases — users report average savings of 20-30 cents per gallon on qualifying transactions.
Check if your grocery store offers fuel rewards. Kroger, Safeway, Giant, and many regional chains discount gas by 10-50 cents per gallon tied to grocery spending thresholds.
Use regular unleaded unless your owner's manual specifically requires premium. For the majority of vehicles, there is zero performance benefit from a higher grade.
Plan fill-ups along your existing commute route rather than making special trips. A station you pass daily that is 10 cents cheaper beats a special detour to a slightly better price.